Duane Morris energy attorneys assist clients with advisory, regulatory, litigation, transactional and legislative matters involving environmental, energy and natural resources issues. A registered patent attorney, he uses his background in biomedical engineering to prosecute even the most challenging patent applications for medical device technologies. Her trial experience includes bet the company cases with several hundreds of millions at stake, e.g., In re Certain Multi-Stage Fuel Vapor Canister Systems and Activated Carbon Components Thereof (Inv. As in-house counsel, Alex developed strategy and managed dozens of patent cases in 5 countries, including 3 ITC trials, District Court cases, a UK trial, a German trial, and 2 China cases . The rarity of being a Black intellectual property lawyer in the United States hits home for the 1.7% of attorneys who fit that description. Organizations like the National Bar Association, the largest national network of predominantly African American attorneys and judges, or the Chicago Black Partners Alliance can provide lists. I was lucky enough to land in places where people saw something in me, and I was willing to receive it, said Waldrop, who is the head of Kasowitzs Silicon Valley office. By comparison, 5% of attorneys in the U.S. are Black, according to the American Bar Association. Email: info@allgaierpatentsolutions.com, Reviving an abandoned trademark application, THE ROLE LICENSES PLAY IN INCREASING BUSINESS REVENUE. 497,747 in 1893 for an improvement on Broom Moisteners and Bridles. The rights to the invention were assigned at issue to Miriam, and she signed the document as the patent attorney (you can view her signature at the bottom of the linked patent drawing). The ramifications go beyond individual inventors. Just based on the number of employees within each industry, we were able to determine the most common industries that employ patent attorneys. Patent Priority: the First Woman Patent Lawyer Benjamins influence and persistence in legislative matters can be detected in her extended dealings with Congress. There are over 3,943 Patent Attorneys in the United States. Drayton said he too benefited from a black role model: former Cooley partner Daniel Johnson Jr., now of the Dan Johnson Law Group. Johnson highlights another contributing factor: low numbers of Black intellectual property attorneys. Well-versed in all aspects of intellectual property law, Jamaal focuses his practice on preparing and prosecuting patents in the U.S. and abroad. He believes that, with the pandemic as a backdrop, the message is getting through that we are all one community that must watch out for each other and take active steps to keep each other safe, Turner said. Waldrop was asking himself, Do I really want to do this? So youre starting from a limited population to begin with, said Azuka Dike, a patent attorney at Banner Witcoff who is a liaison to the American Bar Associations Commission on Racial and Ethnic Diversity in the Profession. The National Black Lawyers was created to celebrate legal excellence by promoting our attorneys as subject-matter experts, developing a strong national network of top African American attorneys, and facilitating the exchange of timely information to enable our members to maintain their status as leaders. So hes imploring in-house counsel not to turn to the same old network every time a new matter comes in. Ultimately, there might be valid reasons for choosing another lawyer. Woods developed the railroad telegraph; Julian figured out how to synthesize different hormones, including cortisone. Kasowitz Benson Torres partner Jonathan Waldrop credits equal parts luck, hard work and good timing for his success as a patent litigator. All three credit mentorssome black, some whitewith making a difference in their careers. You could start there, she said. An Ounce of Prevention Smart Patent Prosecution Can Minimize Litigation Oops (Article. When I introduce myself at conferences or events and give my elevator pitch, the surprise is often palpable.. Use our chart to find out where that salary is located. ***I am indebted to Barbara Levergood of the Bowdoin College library and Rene Bosman at UNC-Chapel Hill, for their generous assistance in locating these bills. While they continue to make big strides and literally raise the bar across all practice areas of law, here are 10 black female attorneys you should know. Growing Mineola firm with national practice seeks associate (with 3-6 years experience) to handle complex general liability matters.Competit CASH KRUGLER & FREDERICKS LLC is Celebrating Our 20th Anniversary & Newest Partners! Prior to attending law school, Ms. Allgaier worked as a research associate in the Section of Leukocyte Biology at Baylor College of Medicine. Jamaalfrequently lectures on intellectual property law to attorneys and other professionals. All of us should feel terrible about black women making up less than 1% of the equity partners in law firms, Gills said. High Rewards (Chair, F&L 8th Annual IP Conference, 10/12), Hot Topics in IP (in light of Apple v. Samsung & AIA) (BWLA Presentation, 10/12), IP Law Update (covering recent Trade Dress/Patent Decisions & AIA) (Client CLE, 9/12), An Overview of US Patent Reform (The America Invents Act) (Client CLE, 11/11), Patent Wars: The Game Show-Prosecutors vs. Litigators and author In Drafting A Joint Development Agreement, Who Should Own The Jointly Developed IP? (AIPLA Annual Meeting, 10/11), The Exponential Speed of Innovation: Is IP Driving Your Business? (Chair, F&L 7th Annual IP Conference, 9/11), Winning a Game of Inches: Gaining Momentum Through IP (Chair, F&L 6th Annual IP Conference, 10/10), Patenting Business Methods and Other Recent Developments (Client CLE, 1/10), Being A Partner (F&L Presentation, 1/10), What IP Issues Keep General Counsel Up At Night? (Chair/Panelist, F&L 5th Annual IP Conference, 10/09), Extracting Value from IP in the Reform Era: What It Takes to Build and Protect Your Core Assets in Uncertain Times (Argyle Corporate Leadership Forum, 9/09), Networking For Success (F&L Mentor/Mentee Seminar, 6/09), Emerging Legal Trends In Patent Law (MCCA CLE Expo, 3/09), IP Gone Wild? (Moderator and Panelist, F&L 4th Annual IP Conference, 9/08), Strategic Patent LitigationVenue Selection, Use of IP Injunctions & Defenses (IP Section Mtg. That was pivotal, Waldrop said. On what other basis would you think that I couldnt possibly be [on the committee] other than my skin color or gender? she said. Black or african american patent attorneys have the lowest average salary at $82,666. Another study, from Michigan State University researchers, found that from 1976 to 2008, African American inventors were awarded six patents per 1 million people, compared to 235 patents per 1 million for all U.S. inventors. Every case is different and must be judged on its own merits. Many Black law students arent exposed to IP as a career path. She is also frequently quoted by publications such as Law360, Managing Intellectual Property, BNAs Patent Trademark & Copyright Journal, and The Wall Street Journal. Patent attorneys team up with SLU professor in development and patenting of mask made specifically for singers and others whose voice is the foundation of their livelihood. Law Offices of Gary Martin Hays & Associates But more than 90 percent of American Intellectual Property Law Association survey respondents said they were admitted to the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office bar, which is required to practice in agency matters like prosecuting clients patent applications. Maybe some of those individuals will then go to law schools and become lawyers. If such an individual doesnt exist at their law firm, say to them, If you want to keep my business, hire some additional individuals to put on my team.. Lawyers and other IP professionals also have a responsibility to help diverse entrepreneurs and inventors, said Deborah Lodge, a partner at Squire Patton Boggs who has participated in New Voices Foundation educational programs about IP protection. The list did not include any patent litigators. Patent Attorney Demographics and Statistics In The US - Zippia With Such Low Win Rates, Should Law Firms Respond to So Many RFPs? Toomey got a patent in 1930 for an appliance to prevent ice on airplanes. Gills Quoted in The Recorder About Systemic Racism Facing Black Patent To contact the reporter on this story: Matthew Bultman in New York at mbultman@correspondent.bloomberglaw.com, To contact the editors responsible for this story: Keith Perine at kperine@bloomberglaw.com; Cheryl Saenz at csaenz@bloombergtax.com, Learn more about a Bloomberg Law subscription, Photo Illustration; Jonathan Hurtarte/Bloomberg Law; Photos: Getty Images, Photo by Thomas S. England/The LIFE Images Collection via Getty Images/Getty Images; Photo by Kean Collection/Getty Images; Photo by Bettmann Archive/Getty Images, federal intellectual property legislation, Black inventors vastly underrepresented in patent system, Scholars say diversity gap has deep historical roots. 1928-2014. Nelson Madden Black LLP Attorneys Website (212) 382-4300 5 Park Row New York, NY 10038 CLOSED NOW 6. Each attorney is granted unlimited access to high quality, on-demand premium content from well-respected faculty in the legal industry along with administrative access to easily manage CLE for the entire team. By looking over 961 patent attorneys resumes, we figured out that the average patent attorney enjoys staying at their job for 1-2 years for a percentage of 32%. Those industries include professional, manufacturing and technology. She is a staunch champion of diversity in the legal profession and is a founding member of the Black Patent Network and the Chicago Black Partner Alliance. With little recourse to the courts, African Americans would have found it nearly impossible to fight patent infringement, even if they had been represented by white attorneys, Cook wrote. Samuel Newman, of Bowdoin College, Old School? 5.7% of Patent Attorneys are Black or African American, Most a are White, with 75.3% of Patent Attorneys belonging to this ethnicity. Terms of Service. The racial divide persists for many reasons that dont lend themselves to simple fixes. Shreveport Uzezi Abugo Uzezi Abugo, Attorney at Law Michael Acquah Hueston Hennigan LLP Los Angeles Michael Adams DeCuir, Clark & Adams, LLP Where are the Women and Minority Patent Professionals? He was 30 years old when he was granted a patent for a dry-cleaning process. Early History of African American Inventors - ThoughtCo Turner, whose practice covers intellectual property litigation and strategy, is encouraged that a national and international conversation is springing up around systemic racism faced by African Americans. Dynamically explore and compare data on law firms, companies, individual lawyers, and industry trends. This will further equip us to play a pivotal role in driving meaningful changes and ensuring that our voices are heard. Previously, Dr. Black was a member of the legal affairs department at 3M Company where he supported 3Ms optical and display business units. This section highlights information about where patent attorneys work. Black Economist's Research Finds A Blindspot On A Theory Of - NPR Her second invention was a sole for footwear that was patented in 1917 in the United States and in Canada. Gills, however, was prepared for whatever curveball he could throw at me, and the GC decided to hire her on. Its almost hard to know where to start, Gills said. B. Legalweek New York explores Business and Regulatory Trends, Technology and Talent drivers impacting law firms. The offices of patent attorneys (all white at the time) were in white-only commercial districts, hindering African American inventors from applying for patents, Cook wrote in an often-cited 2013 study that examined patent activity from 1870 to 1940. About Us| During law school, she worked in the Law Office of the Cook County Public Defender as a senior law student, representing clients who had been charged with misdemeanors and felonies. I had the privilege of being a part of a trial team in my first year where Mr. Johnson was the first-chair trial lawyer for a co-defendant, Drayton said. Employees with the patent attorney job title have their preferences when it comes to working for a company. Other PTO efforts to close the gap for women and minorities include launching the Expanding Innovation Hub, with resources for inventors, and programs like Camp Invention, a STEM program for elementary-aged students. Patent attorneys are most in-demand in Los Angeles, CA. Well seek to provide greater mentorship opportunities. She Persisted at Law and Legislative Matters. Well-versed in all aspects of intellectual property law, Jamaal focuses his practice on preparing and prosecuting patents in the U.S. and abroad. From there, a firm can pay for the candidate to take the patent offices bar exam, meaning the candidate can then help clients in the process of obtaining a patent. It was great to see a prominent lawyer who looked like me; it materially contributed to my vision of success. Before 1900, Cook finds patenting rates were lower for Black inventors than white inventors, but followed similar patterns increasing during economic booms, decreasing during downturns. After earning a B.S. Claims that black inventors filed patents under the names of white attorneys seem absurd: under U.S. patent laws, any such patents would be invalid, as even the most incompetent lawyer would know; and there was no reason at all to do so, since all applications were submitted in writing and it was impossible for anyone at the patent office to identify the inventors race. In an hour-long meeting, Gills was asked questions about a statutes legislative history, which had nothing to do with issues in the case. One of the first Black women in U.S. history to receive a patent, she expanded upon . We determined the average age of patent attorneys based on ethnicity and gender. Don't miss the crucial news and insights you need to make informed legal decisions. She was similarly the attorney of record, when her younger brother, Edgar P. Benjamin (18691972), received U.S. patent no. A lot of what keeps you in it is, Im part of the team. That can move the needle. Protecting And Enforcing Trade Secrets (AIPLA 2016 Spring Meeting), Check, Raise, or Fold: The Risky Business of IP (Chair, F&L 11th Annual IP Conference, 9/15), Trade Secret Protection and Enforcement in the U.S. (NBA Annual Conference, 7/15), Patents/Trade Secrets Overview (Client CLE, 4/15 and 7/15), Whats next? Although formal barriers to the patent system were removed with the abolition of slavery and the passage of the 14th Amendmentwhich guarantees citizenship to anyone born in the U.S.studies show Black inventors continued to face legal and societal obstacles. Likewise Foley & Lardner partner Jeanne Gills, a member of the firms management committee. How many patents by African Americans were there in the "golden age of Call our Georgia Criminal Appeals Lawyers today at 1- (770) 284-3147 to schedule your free initial consultation so our attorneys can review your case. We've been helping experienced inventors, first-time inventors, and businesses (and their in-house legal teams) protect their inventions and brands with patents and trademarks since 2004. When it comes to protecting your intellectual property, patents and trademarks are essential. According to the 2019 edition, 5% of lawyers are African American, . Jeanne also serves as vice chair of the firms national Intellectual Property Department focusing on Strategic Marketing & Business Development, and she previously served as vice chair of the Intellectual Property Litigation Practice. She previously served on the board of the Illinois Campaign for Political Reform and previously served for six years on the Evening Associates Board of the Art Institute of Chicago and mentored high school students through Links Unlimited. The First African-American to Hold a Patent Invented 'Dry Scouring' Women, Influence & Power in Law UK Awards honors women lawyers who have made a remarkable difference in the legal profession. Like Turner, Drayton believes that the COVID-19 pandemic has eliminated many of the distractions of day-to-day life, creating something of a captive audience for the injustices that have been unfurling in Minneapolis and elsewhere. Duane Morris LLP - Offices - Newark I have seen, in my career, people who presume from the outset that I could not be handed much responsibility, because they didnt think I belonged in the responsibility-carrying club, Smith said. With her electronics background and given her attorney registration to practice before the USPTO, Jeannes broad-based IP experience also includes: counseling related to product configuration trade dress and use of color as a trademark; handling TTAB and UDRP matters; resolving copyright ownership disputes, particularly in the areas of computer software and associated documentation; handling contractual disputes concerning IP rights and the theft or use of IP by a companys former employees, business partners and/or independent contractors; counseling clients on IP holding companies, including how to maximize value from an IP portfolio when certain assets are likely to be the subject of IP litigation; handling cases involving the intersection of trade dress, design patent, and utility patent protection for consumer and industrial products; and conducting discovery abroad throughout Europe, Singapore and Japan. 10 Sure-Fire Ways to Ignite Your Passion and Career! (CCWC, 9/17), Current and Emerging Issues Related to Patents (Client CLE, 3/17), Get Ready Now! Lawyers do XYZ. Science, technology, engineering and math (STEM) education isnt required to practice IP law, including patent litigation. Benjamin trained to be a teacher in a Massachusetts normal school, and in 1884 passed the civil service exam very creditably, allowing her to work as a federal government clerk in Washington D.C. Four years later, in 1888, she enrolled in the Medical School at Howard University, but dropped out in the first year. Do I matter? Which State Has The Most Patent Attorneys? Part of the reason: The path to advancement at a law firm is to be a lead lawyer on a matter, Turner said. Being laser focused on the opportunities afforded Black lawyers and the outcomes will allow firms to course correct for any potential disparate impact associated with long standing practices, Drayton said. The underrepresentation of Black inventors, and documented disparities in numbers of women and Hispanic inventors, was acknowledged in a patent office report to Congress last fall. But if they dont open the pool to see whats out there, they dont know what theyre missing., Turner notes that the underrepresentation of black attorneys is far from a new issue. On the Early Breakfast Relebogile Mabotja spoke to the First Black Female Patent . Stan Gibson is a trial lawyer who focuses on high-stakes cases involving technology. There are relatively simple steps that firms can take too. As the founder of Allgaier Patent Solutions, she represents clients throughout theUnited Stateswho need legal assistance with regard to patents, trademarks, and copyrights. Government has tried to take some steps, but progress has been slow. Thomas L. Jennings (1791-1859), for example, learned tailoring and dry cleaning and carried on that business in New York City, where in 1821, at the age of 30, he received a patent for an improvement in dry cleaning processes perhaps the first black person in this country to have received one . Surfing Trademark Issues on the Web (F&L White Paper, 9/06; Crafting an Effective Patent Invalidity OpinionIs it the Last Bastion of Defense? (PLI, 2003-2006; Being and Finding Good Mentors (BWLA, 3/06), Trade Secret Protection in the 21st Century (F&L Litigation Conference, 12/05), The Dilution DilemmaLitigating Dilution Claims and the Trademark Dilution Revision Act of 2005 (ABA/Navigant Consulting IP Roundtable, 12/05), IP Roundtable on Key Patent Appellate Cases, including, Digital, Wireless & New Media TechnologiesIs Your IP Future in the Right Hands? (Chair/Founder, F&L 1st Annual IP Conference, 9/05), "Discovery Issues in Patent Litigation (PLI, 9/05), Internet-Related Trademark Litigation Issues & Trends (INTA, 5/05), New Insights into IP Law in ChinaPresenter on Trade Secret Protection (F&L Corporate Counsel Seminar, 3/05), Preparing to Initiate or Defend a Patent Lawsuit (ABA, 10/04), IP Litigation: Avoiding the Money Pit (, How Do You Measure Up? 475,749 for a bicycle clip in 1892, two years before he graduated from Boston University School of Law. As you can see, patent examiner and patent attorney have the biggest difference in gender. Protecting And Enforcing Trade Secrets, Article: Whats Reasonable?Protecting And Enforcing Trade Secrets, Justices Craft Their Own Remedy for Violation of Constitutions Appointments Clause, Justices Scale Back Unreviewable Authority of Administrative Patent Judges, Justices Appear Conflicted About Status of Administrative Patent Judges, Justices To Consider Appointments Clause Challenge To Administrative Patent Judges, Trademark, Copyright & Advertising Counseling, Trademark, Copyright & Advertising Litigation, Foley Attorneys Named to 2023 Illinois Super Lawyers List, Jeanne M. Gills Named an Honoree at Corporate Counsel 2022 Women, Influence and Power in Law Awards, Foley Attorneys Recognized in 2023 Best Lawyers in America, Foley Represents The League in Acquisition by Match Group, 16th Annual IP Conference (Virtual): Knowing When and How to Pivot 2.0, Health Plan Transparency in Coverage Rule, The University of Chicago Law School (J.D., 1994), Michigan State University (B.S., with honors, electrical engineering, 1991), Ready to Respond: A Roadmap for Diverse Attorneys to Serve on Corporate Boards (CMCP Virtual Seminar, 3/21), General Counsel BootcampIntellectual Property (Client CLE, 2/21), Diversity & Inclusion: Beyond the Boardroom (F&L National Directors Institute, 11/20), Knowing When and How to Pivot 2.0 (Chair, F&L 16th Annual IP Conference, 10/20), Elevate: How to Breakthrough Your Inner Glass Ceiling & Reclaim Your Power to Lead (CCWC 16th Annual Conference, 9/20), Recent Developments in Patent Law & Best Practices with Patent Opinions (Client CLE, 6/20), 2019 PTAB Year In Review (F&L Webinar, 1/20), When and How to Pivot (Chair, F&L 15th Annual IP Conference, 10/19), Advanced, Patent Litigation Seminar (Chair, PLI, Chicago, 2009-2018), Proving and Guarding the Real Economic Value of IP (Chair, F&L 14th Annual IP Conference, 9/18), Trade Secrets Protection, Enforcement, and Litigation (Sandpiper Partners LLC, 6/18), Diversity & Inclusion (Law Bulletin Ethics Seminar, 6/18), Top Ten Tips for a Successful Mediation in Intellectual Property Cases (AIPLA Annual Meeting Presentation and Article, 10/17), Forging Ahead: Strategies for the New Unknown (Chair and Speaker, F&L 13th Annual IP Conference, 10/17), Chicago Black Partners Alliance, Marshall Movie Premiere Event (10/17), Career Not Moving Fast Enough? In January 2006, Ms. Bashen became the first African American female to hold a patent for a software invention. 79% of Patent Attorneys are male, and 20% are female, so there are more male Patent Attorneys than female Patent Attorneys in the United States. Henry E. Baker, a black patent examiner who was appointed in 1876, underlined that the patent system was colorblind; and neither the laws nor the administration excluded or differentiated on the basis of personal characteristics. Black people and other minority inventors have been left behind for many reasons, including too few resources, a lack of access to capital, and a low level of awareness of the patenting system in general, according to consultant Janeya Griffin. National Association of Minority & Women Owned Law Firms | NAMWOLF Jamaal was selected by judges, bar groups and fellow attorneys for his work, leadership and community service. When clients and law firm rainmakers invest in and bet on black IP attorneys, good things tend to happen, Drayton said. He made me the leader of the Silicon Valley office. The technical knowledge of handling a trial, and the marketability of that knowledgethat could never be taken from me. We do some outreach to undergrads, and even students in middle and high school., Recruitment, said Joseph Drayton, a Cooley LLP partner and former National Bar Association president, should be followed with proper training, access to premium work including repetition in assignments specific to patent matters, tracking of work and success in execution of assignments.. Hollin can help you with patents, trademarks, and infringement issues. ABWA is partnering with the Dominican Bar Association to host a series of police reform webinars, which will update our members on the steps that are being taken to ensure more just policing practices. As an African American Patent Attorney, she is an active member of The Chicagos first Black Inventors Organization and provides assistance to African American Inventors throughout the United States. A Pioneering Black Woman Patent Attorney February 1, 2023 By Zorina Khan Like millions of innovative individuals, MIRIAM E. BENJAMIN (1861-1947) was active in multiple inventive markets, as the patentee of two inventions, and assignee on another. According to a recent article in Bloomberg Law, black intellectual property attorneys, in general, make up only 1.7% of all IP attorneys, based on a survey by the American Intellectual Property Law Association. *** In 1906, the Boston Daily Globe reported that Through the untiring efforts of Miss Miriam E. Benjamin of Boston, a clerk in one of the Departments at Washington, $10,482 has been awarded Samuel Lee, a negro, who was elected to congress 25 years ago, but never sworn in. Benjamin lobbied to bring the bill to aid Samuel Lee before Congress nine times, until it finally passed in 1906. 'Take That On': Black Patent Attorneys Say It's Time They Are Our estimates are verified against BLS, Census, and current job openings data for accuracy. I think that also plays a role because we dont see ourselves being owners of intellectual property.. CAN I USE MY TRADEMARK ON PROMOTIONAL ITEMS? When you look at that requirement, you must then consider the population of black college students, or post-college grads that have that technical background. The average Patent Attorney is 46 years old. Well also continue to have events that arm us with the tools we need to thrive professionally. After finding the gender ratio, we wondered if the percentages of LGBT persons were different as well. But there are not zero, he said. Here is the list of the first female attorneys registered to practice before the U.S. Patent Office: 26 Griswold, Miss Edith J., 220 Broadway, New York, NY 198 Lockwood, Belva A., 619 F street, Washington, D. C. 612 Moran, Miss M. L., Washington, D. C. 685 King, Florence H., 1564 Monadnock Building, Chicago, Ill NextGen IPs founder, Flo Donovan, said the only way to ensure in my life-time that minority inventors are included in the patent process was to create a foundation for this purpose.. https://www.law.com/therecorder/2020/06/12/take-that-on-black-patent-attorneys-say-its-time-they-are-recognized/. Im on the executive committee of the firm. With nearly 450 attorneys in 13 offices nationwide, we take pride in our collaborative approach, our lasting relationships and our unique perspectives. Whites are over three times more likely to become inventors as Blacks, Harvard University researchers found in 2018. Criminal Appeal Lawyers In Georgia | Find Georgia Appeal Attorneys Born as Marguerite Johnson on April 4, 1928, Maya Angelou was a renowned poet, educator, and civil rights activist who moved to the Bay Area at the age of 14. With this subscription you will receive unlimited access to high quality, online, on-demand premium content from well-respected faculty in the legal industry. And firms must provide mentors and advocates for young attorneys. Jamaal R. Jordan, Attorney - Intellectual Property and - Stinson Yes, Patent Attorney jobs are male - dominated. When Griffin polled colleagues and clients, who ranged from small business owners to NASA engineers, on when they learned about patents, and that they had value, most said either in graduate school or after starting their careers. Her litigation experience has dovetailed into counseling clients on global IP strategy, including work on the division of patent/technology assets for Kraft Foods 2012 split (into Kraft Foods and Mondelz) and leading the IP side of M&A transactions, such as work on potential $4 billion acquisition in power technology space and recent $1.2 billion deal involving the creation on behalf of power technology companies two JV entities (one in the U.S. and one in Switzerland).

Threaded Hole Callout Gd&t, Nathanael Coe Masterchef, Mark Munch'' Bishop Fired, Articles A